The Visible Signature of Ozone at Twilight

Edited from material contributed by Robert Fosbury, Andreas Seifahrt and Enric Pallé and Ocean Optics

Discoveries in Exoplanet Research

Over the past 15 years, astronomers have identified more than 450 exoplanets—planets outside our solar system. Due to the limitations of current discovery techniques, most of these planets are gas giants similar to Jupiter and orbit close to their parent stars. While a few smaller, rocky planets known as „super-Earths” have been found, the discovery of a true „exoearth” within the habitable zone remains beyond our technological reach. However, the potential to discover such planets in the near future has spurred significant interest in how to characterize them and their atmospheres.

Introduction

It took millennia of sky-gazing before we understood why the daytime sky is blue, a phenomenon explained by Rayleigh scattering. However, this theory does not account for the full spectrum of colors we see at dawn and dusk. It wasn’t until the mid-20th century that scientists realized the unstable ozone molecule (O3) profoundly influences twilight colors.

The ozone layer not only protects Earth from harmful ultraviolet radiation but also affects the color of the twilight sky. Without ozone, the sky at twilight would appear pale green or straw yellow instead of the deep, steely blue we observe. This change is due to the Chappuis absorption band of ozone, which becomes significant during sunrise and sunset when sunlight’s path through the atmosphere is longest. During these times, the Chappuis band is the dominant feature in the visible spectrum of the sky.

Experimental Observations

In preparation for future „transit spectroscopy”—analyzing the light transmitted by a planet’s atmosphere as it passes in front of its star—researchers have conducted spectrophotometry of the twilight sky. These observations can be compared with those of the eclipsed Moon, where light grazes Earth’s atmosphere during a lunar eclipse, resulting in strong suppression of the blue end of the spectrum due to Rayleigh and aerosol extinction.

Using an Ocean Optics Jaz spectrometer covering 350-1000 nm and a single optical fiber input pointed about 10° above the western sky, twilight spectra were obtained in overcast conditions at an altitude of 560 meters and a latitude of +47.8°. The experimental setup included the Jaz spectrometer, a fiber feed, and a data-taking laptop, as shown in Figure 1.

Figure 1. The experimental setup for the twilight observa- tions comprises the Jaz spectrometer, the fiber feed and the data-taking laptop. These photographs, taken around the time of sunset with a “daylight” white balance setting on a Canon 5D Mark II, illustrate the high color temperature of the ambient light at sunset, which is caused predominantly by the ozone absorption (Figure 2).

The spectra revealed variations in sky brightness at 700 nm and color temperature measured with a Gossen Colormaster 2F color meter. This simple experiment highlighted the significant impact of ozone absorption on twilight colors, with the color temperature of the western sky ranging from 6,000 K to 14,000 K (Figure 2). These findings suggest a strong visible spectral signature of an oxygen-rich exoearth atmosphere during transit spectroscopy.

Figure 2. These spectra reveal variation of sky brightness at 700 nm, in units of counts per 8192 ms, and color temperature measured with a Gossen Colormaster 2F color meter.

Results

The absence of strong O2 and H2O signatures in the spectral ratios likely indicates that most light entered the spectrometer from above the cloud layer, where ozone dominates absorption. The twilight spectra, captured at approximately 10-minute intervals from an hour before to 15 minutes after sunset, demonstrated the development of ozone Chappuis absorption centered at 600 nm. The data also showed the dramatic bluish tint of the sky during this period, despite variable cloud thickness (Figure 3).

Figure 3. A sequence of relative irradiance spectra is captured under a cloudy western sky at approximately 10-minute intervals from an hour before, to 15 minutes after, sunset. Also plotted is the lunar eclipse spectrum from [3]. The rapid development of the ozone Chappuis absorption, centered at 600 nm, is apparent together with the dramatic bluish tint of the sky color during this period. The somewhat irregular behavior of the blue end of the spectrum is due to the variable cloud thickness during these measurements. The reference spectrum is taken with a solar altitude of +13° and the final spectrum of the sequence is with an altitude of -3°.

An interesting aspect of this data is the potential to derive the ozone Chappuis absorption cross-section multiplied by the column density of the atmospheric pathlength characteristic of these twilight observations. The observed ratio, compared to atmospheric models using the HITRAN database, illustrated the pure ozone absorption and combined ozone, O2, and H2O absorption (Figure 4).

Figure 4. The observed ratio (dark blue), with a normal- ized continuum, of a spectrum taken with a solar altitude of-3° is compared to one at +13°. Atmospheric models [4] using the HITRAN database (cfa.harvard.edu/hitran) [5], with similar but pure transmission geometry, are over plotted (red: pure ozone absorption; light blue: ozone + O2 + H2O). The models have been scaled in intensity by a factor of 1.7 as a way of accounting for the simplification of the model geometry.

Conclusion

The study of twilight colors through relative spectrophotometry offers insights into the role of ozone in Earth’s atmosphere. This research has implications for characterizing exoplanet atmospheres, particularly in identifying oxygen-rich exoearths. By understanding the visible spectral signatures influenced by ozone, we move closer to interpreting the atmospheres of distant worlds.

References

  1. Pesic, P., “Sky in a Bottle,” The MIT Press
  2. Hulbert, E. O., 1953, “Explanation of the Brightness and Color of the Sky, Particularly the Twilight Sky,” Journal of the Optical Society of America, 43, 113-118
  3. Pallé, E. et al. 2009, “Earth’s transmission spectrum from lunar eclipse observations,” Nature, 459, 814-816
  4. Clough, S.A., et al. 2005, “Atmospheric radiative transfer modeling: a summary of the AER Codes,” Journal of Quantitative Spectroscopy and Radiative Transfer, 91, 233
  5. Rothman L.S., et al. 2009, “The HITRAN 2008 molecular spectroscopic database,” Journal of Quantitative Spectroscopy and Radiative Transfer, 110, 533

Editorial and research information were generously provided by Robert Fosbury, formerly of the Space Telescope-European Coordinating Facility, and Andreas Seifart of the University of California at Davis. Enric Pallé provided the lunar eclipse data.

Scroll to Top